Replacement Theology



Around 400 AD, Augustine of Hippo (among others) propagated the belief that the Gentile church replaced Israel in the plan of God. Thus, REPLACEMENT THEOLOGY. After the Reformation other churches were established and many continued this belief.       Today, in most Christian churches, a portion of the attendees still believe that the church has replaced Israel. That the Bride of Christ, the gentile church, comes first and Israel has been deserted, thrown away.

I thought back to years before, when I was a new Christian. I remembered hearing that the Jews were responsible for Jesus’ death and it seemed to me that there was a feeling of hate attached to this. At first I felt that hate but, because of Jesus’ grace, I didn’t dwell on it. I simply read my Bible and in the living scriptures found faith and hope, two things that brought me peace and understanding.

Because this subject has come up again, especially of late, I decided to take a look at what I had learned from the Bible, to see if there was any support for this claim. This is my personal observation on the subject, using scripture as my guide.

No, the Gentile Church has not replaced Israel in God’s plan.   Abraham was a righteous man and God blessed him, his son and his grandson. The Lord our God gave a perpetual land covenant to the Israeli people, beginning with Abraham through to his grandson Jacob, or Israel, and his twelve sons and their descendants who are the nation of Israel.  The Bible clearly states that salvation comes “to the Jew first, and also to the Greek” (or Gentile), Romans 1:16. This scripture provides insight into the love God has for the Jew.  Consider John 4:22  “for salvation is of the Jews.”

What other things show us that God hasn’t forgotten the Hebrews? Well, He promised to bring his chosen people back into the Promised Land (land He promised, starting with Abram, later to be changed to Abraham). On May 15th, 1948 Israel was reborn and the twelve tribes have been finding their way back home ever since. God made them a promise that they would never be taken off that land again. Does this sound like we have replaced Israel in God’s plan? No.

Go and read Isaiah 54:5-17 before considering REPLACEMENT THEOLOGY.       Consider Isaiah 54 verse 17.  “No weapon that is formed against you shall be blessed; and every tongue that shall rise against you in judgment, you shall condemn. This is the inheritance of the servants of Jehovah, and their righteousness is from Me, says Jehovah.”  This scripture is for the Israelites. Christ had not yet died for our sins. It could not be the church.

I personally believe that, as a born again Christian, I am a sister to the Israelis. My Lord is Jewish as they are.  I am grafted in on the Olive Tree, with the same adopted rights as them, but I don’t replace them.

How can I face God Almighty on that great and final judgment day—brothers and sisters let me tell you one is coming—after mistreating His Israelite sons and daughters.  I believe Replacement Theology is a lie and is perpetrated by a dark deceptive spirit. There’s just too much hate attached to it toward God’s Children.

I didn’t come to this conclusion without knowledge of what I write. I have thirty-eight years of scriptural references behind me. (I consider this my credentials.)

Consider the last eight years.  I have read the King James Bible 4 times. All reading is from Genesis through Revelation.       The Living Bible Paraphrased three times.       The King James Chronological Bible two times.       I am currently working on the next read through of all three Bibles.

If you find yourself on my page, it’s my belief it’s not by accident. I pray you will consider what I’ve written and if you have difficulty believing it, go to the Bible and see what it says for yourself.

All comments are welcome, unless you want an argument, which I don’t. If that’s the case please take it to the Lord our God and debate it with Him. He’s the One who says it.

Father, I pray a blessing for each and every person who comes to this site and reads what I have written. I pray You guide them in their search. I ask You hear this in Jesus’ name.

5 thoughts on “Replacement Theology

  1. Pingback: Thoughts About ‘Replacement Theology’ | Seek Ye First…

  2. Hey, Pat, good article. I’m firmly convinced Israel still has a major place in God’s heart. New insight: I’ve read my Bible for 23 years, and knew the no weapon Scripture was in Isaiah–but never really noticed it isn’t in the New Testament. Thanks, Grace. (201)

  3. Good post, Pat. We were most definitely grafted in. I wish those who believed in Replacement Theology would read the following verses: “And if some of the branches be broken off, and thou, being a wild olive tree, wert grafted in among them, and with them partakest of the root and fatness of the olive tree: boast not against the branches, but if thou boast, thou bearest not the root, but the root thee,” (Romans 11:17-18 KJV).

    The above verse states we were grafted in among them, not in place of them. Israel is the natural branch. You have to have an original branch to graft in another. If not, then God could have simply planted a completely new tree, but He didn’t. We share the root and fatness of the tree with them.

    The next few verses apply to the reason Israel was broken off (the stems of the branches, not the root), and those who speak against them. “Well; because of unbelief they were broken off, and thou standest by faith. Be not highminded, but fear: For if God spared not the natural branches, take heed lest he also spare not thee” (Romans 11:20-21 KJV).”

    Sorry this is so lengthy, but it struck a chord with me.

    • Deb, Thank you very much. Anything that strikes a chord with us is timely. Maybe it is time for Christians to be talking more about this. It certainly benefits Israel to know they are not alone.
      I really appreciate your choice in verses.

Leave a Reply to pfreece Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.